The UK Just Opened a Probe Into Hyperscaler Security and Cloud Lock-In
The UK Competition and Markets Authority is probing hyperscaler security and cloud lock-in, opening a consultation on identity systems and Kubernetes as part of its digital sovereignty investigation.

The UK CMA cloud probe opened on November 20: the Competition and Markets Authority is examining hyperscaler security and cloud lock-in, opening a consultation on identity and access management and Kubernetes as part of its ongoing digital sovereignty investigation. The announcement came on November 20, and it is the most concrete step the CMA has taken yet toward deciding whether the cloud market actually works for customers, or only for the companies that run it.
The CMA has been circling this question for years. Its earlier cloud market investigation found that customers face real barriers to switching providers or running workloads across more than one cloud, and that the biggest providers have little incentive to remove those barriers. This new consultation goes deeper, into the specific mechanisms that keep customers in place: the identity systems that control who can access what, and the Kubernetes platforms that orchestrate the containers everything runs on.
UK CMA Cloud Probe: Why IAM and Kubernetes Are the Lock-In
That choice of targets is telling. Identity and access management is the least visible and most powerful form of lock-in in cloud computing. Once a company's users, permissions, roles, and security policies live inside one provider's identity system, moving is not a matter of copying files. It is a matter of rebuilding the security model of the entire organization, and doing it without breaking anything in the middle. Most companies look at that job and decide to stay.
Kubernetes is the other side of the same coin. It was supposed to be the great equalizer, an open standard that lets workloads run anywhere. In practice, each hyperscaler's managed Kubernetes service adds its own extensions, integrations, and defaults, and those differences accumulate until moving a workload means re-testing and re-tuning it. The CMA is asking whether that drift is an accident of engineering or a feature of the business model. That is a polite way of asking whether the hyperscalers are quietly rebuilding the walls that open standards were meant to tear down.
The sovereignty angle matters too. The investigation is explicitly about digital sovereignty, which is regulator language for a simple question: can the UK's businesses and public services actually control their own digital infrastructure, or do they rent it on terms set elsewhere? That question has become sharper as governments and regulated industries put more critical systems in the cloud, and as the biggest providers become more entangled with AI infrastructure that everyone depends on.
What Happens Next
A consultation is not a ruling, and it would be a mistake to read it as one. The CMA is gathering evidence, and the hyperscalers will argue, with some justification, that their identity and Kubernetes services are more secure and better integrated precisely because they are built for their own platforms. Security and lock-in are often the same engineering decision viewed from opposite sides, and the CMA's job is to tell them apart.
But the direction of travel is clear. The CMA has already used its strategic market status powers against Microsoft over Copilot, and it has shown it is willing to act in cloud markets rather than just study them. A consultation on IAM and Kubernetes is the groundwork for remedies, and the remedies in this space tend to be concrete: requirements to support standard identity protocols, limits on egress fees, or obligations to keep managed services interoperable.
For cloud customers, the practical takeaway is to treat portability as a requirement, not a nice-to-have, in the next contract negotiation. Ask how your identity setup would move, what your Kubernetes workloads depend on that is provider-specific, and what the exit would actually cost. If your vendor cannot answer those questions clearly, that is itself an answer. The CMA is asking the same questions, and it has the power to make the answers mandatory.


