FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 20, 2026 Tech news, minus the noise.
N News Cast
LATEST
Business

The DOJ Just Told Merger Lawyers It Will Take Promises Instead of Sell-Offs

The US Justice Department said it is open to clearing mergers on behavioral promises rather than asset sales, pointing to its clearance of Fox's $22 billion Roku deal.

The DOJ Just Told Merger Lawyers It Will Take Promises Instead of Sell-Offs
Source: Gunnar Klack (CC BY-SA 4.0)

The US Justice Department is open to approving mergers based on promises about how companies will operate rather than requiring them to sell assets. That is what Charlie Beller, deputy assistant attorney general for antitrust, said on Monday at a conference in New York, pointing to the agency's decision this month to clear Fox Corp.'s $22 billion acquisition of Roku Inc. It is a shift in how Washington polices big deals, and it has immediate consequences for the tech industry's biggest pending acquisition. It is also the biggest change in DOJ merger remedies in years.

What the DOJ actually said

Beller said the DOJ has been focused on how behavioral commitments or remedies serve as a mitigating factor for competition concerns, especially in deals in industries where asset sales may be more difficult to arrange. That is careful bureaucratic language, but the meaning is plain: the department would rather take a company's word that it will behave than force it to sell off parts of the business.

That marks a shift under President Donald Trump. The previous approach, under both parties at various times, treated behavioral remedies with suspicion. The worry was always enforcement: a promise is easy to make and hard to police, while a divestiture is permanent. A company that sells a division cannot un-sell it. A company that promises to play fair can always find a way to define fair in its own favor.

The DOJ's new openness does not mean every deal gets cleared. It means the negotiation has changed. Companies can now offer conduct commitments as a serious alternative to structural remedies, and the department will take them seriously.

Fox and Roku: the test case

The Fox-Roku deal is the proof. The DOJ said on November 6 it was closing its investigation into Fox's $22 billion acquisition of Roku after the company committed to carry non-Fox content for at least three years and continue to provide data products on reasonable terms. No assets were sold. No division was spun off. Fox promised to behave, and the DOJ accepted.

There is a detail that matters. The DOJ opted against filing the Fox-Roku commitments in federal court, bypassing a public process that would have required a judge to scrutinize whether the settlement terms were in the public interest. Under a Watergate-era transparency law, the Tunney Act, the government must outline why it believes an antitrust settlement is in the public interest and allow the public to weigh in. By not filing in court, the DOJ skipped that step.

Key Democrats in Congress have already proposed amending the Tunney Act to require greater public disclosure and strengthen the standard of review by courts. Whether that goes anywhere is an open question, but the criticism is on the record: a behavioral deal that never faces a judge is a behavioral deal that never faces real scrutiny.

Nvidia and Hugging Face are next

Beller's comment also sheds light on how the DOJ may approach its review of Nvidia Corp.'s $13 billion acquisition of AI model company Hugging Face, whose models and data can be freely used by anyone. That deal is the most consequential merger review in tech right now, and the DOJ's new stance changes the calculation for both sides.

Nvidia can now plausibly offer behavioral commitments: promises to keep Hugging Face open, to keep its models freely available, to not favor its own hardware. Under the old approach, those promises might have been dismissed as unenforceable. Under the new approach, they are a live option. That is good news for Nvidia and for anyone who wants the deal to close.

It is also a test of the new policy's limits. Hugging Face is not a streaming service. It is infrastructure for the open AI ecosystem, used by researchers, startups and large companies alike. If Nvidia owns it, the question is not just whether Nvidia will behave but whether the open model ecosystem can survive being owned by the dominant chipmaker. Behavioral promises may not be enough to answer that, and the DOJ knows it.

Why the FTC is not on board

The Federal Trade Commission, which also reviews merger deals, is not moving in the same direction. David Shaw, the agency's number two competition official, said at the same conference that behavioral remedies remain disfavored and rare at the FTC, though regulators sometimes have reasons to accept them rather than pursue lawsuits. That is a polite way of saying the two agencies disagree, and companies will notice.

A split between the DOJ and the FTC creates uncertainty. Deals are reviewed by one agency or the other, and the outcome can depend on which one gets the case. A company that would get a behavioral deal from the DOJ might face a lawsuit from the FTC. That inconsistency is bad for deal planning, and it will push companies to lobby for the friendlier reviewer.

The broader context is a wave of big tech deals that need regulatory approval. Palo Alto Networks is paying $4.5 billion for Applied Compute. Anthropic just priced its IPO at $83 a share. JD.com completed its Ceconomy takeover only after the EU imposed ten-year commitments to share logistics with rivals. The EU, notably, still prefers structural-style conditions with teeth. The US is moving the other way.

The question now is whether behavioral remedies work in practice. The Fox-Roku commitments run for three years. If Fox honors them, the DOJ's bet pays off. If it finds loopholes, the critics will say they told you so. The answer will take years, but the policy shift is happening now.

AS
News Cast Editorial Team

We cover AI, gadgets, startups and security — original reporting and explainers, written by humans, for humans. Got a tip? Reach us via the contact page.